Showing posts with label Battlefield. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Battlefield. Show all posts

Sunday, 15 December 2013

The Little Indie Game That Could - A Call of Duty: Ghosts Review



Written By: Tyler Selig

"AH I CAN'T SEE, EVERYTHING IS BLACK. Oh wait.."


Rating: 6/10
Verdict: Call of Duty: Ghosts is not a new experience. It changes up the formula a tad here and there, but not enough for me to get back into the series. Fans of the series should eat this up as a fun, fast, action packed game… while people who hate the series will find yet another bland military shooter that feels like paper. Pick your side, because Call of Duty is here to stay.

            I’m of the mind that a reviewer should embrace his or her biases, and make them known. I’m not trying to start an argument here (or maybe I am, I don’t know), but I don’t understand this obsession with objectivity. I’m not trying to say that you can’t try to break down the pros and cons of a game in the most unbiased way that’s possible, but a game that is boring for one may be an intense experience for another. Objective turns subjective pretty quick in a lot of cases, and that’s why I will always be upfront with anybody reading this about my own personal prejudices and desires (sounds sexy). It’s also the reason I’ve always enjoyed a system built upon multiple critics reviewing the same game, because that will give a more balanced opinion. Nobody reads my blog, so as much as I’d like to have multiple people reviewing things, it’s just not possible right now.
                So with that out of the way, let’s talk the newest entry in the blockbuster series – Call of Duty: Ghosts. Most people will know what this is, but for those few who don’t, Ghosts is a first-person military shooter based around an elite group named Ghosts, who are known for their great war skills, be it stealth or gunplay.  There’s also a tiny, insignificant sub-plot where the game takes place a few years after the US of A has fallen and the soldiers are fighting to get their country back.
                Call of Duty: Ghosts should please CoD fans, unless they’re the jaded kind that haven’t liked a game in the series since the first Modern Warfare but keep playing each new entry anyway -- there is no hope for them at this point. For the rest of them, I can’t see them being overly unhappy with the game as a whole. I got out of Call of Duty during Modern Warfare 3… just one day I stopped enjoying it as much as I had, and I wasn’t even a massive fan to begin with.        
                This is a major reason for the 6 out of 10. As a Call of Duty, I’d rate it very highly because the developers do what they do really well. If you want a more arcade-style twitch shooter, then CoD is fantastic. For people like me, who now feel that the game just feels like paper and doesn’t feed me like a heavier shooter like Killzone does, then it’s not that enjoyable. I do like it, just not that much, and I feel the game does some things better than previous entries, and some things worse.
                Firstly, I would say the campaign is a step down from what I feel is the best campaign in the series – Modern Warfare 2. I felt this way during MW3 as well. Many have criticized MW2 for its length, but I felt that it was fast-paced and exciting, partially because it didn’t really have time to wear out its welcome. Ghosts is a normal length campaign (8 – 12 hours like most games), but there’s a lot of “been there, done that” going on. There are action set pieces galore, but somehow it just manages to not be thrilling. When I wasn’t so familiar with the series, I could handle the format, but I have a harder time now.
                For example, the series has pretty much always told you what to do. “There’s a helicopter coming, get down,” and so you do. Rinse, repeat. It would be nice if it could get changed up a bit so we have more control over what goes on in the single-player. Let me call some shots outside of, “waiting on you, take the shot.” The game is linear and just gets you from Point A to Point B. Some don’t mind this, but after a game every year, it drains me. I don’t even find the big action movie-esque action as much as I used to. The one level where they open up the game a little bit for you is a welcome change, and I give them props for including that. However, in the end, I’m just a little tired of their brand. I feel that a lot of it just ends up falling flat.
                 The premise of the fallen Amerika is a good one. Setting you up like an underdog fighting for your country should make the game a little more personal and interesting, but it only achieves that mildly. Right from the beginning they stress the idea of family, but really, I couldn't bring myself to care that much because I know that Ghosts is focusing more on blowin' shit up. That's fine, but it just means another Call of Duty campaign with a story I don't care about.
                And you might as well forget about the dog. The dog was an unnecessary addition. There wasn’t really much potential to be extraordinary there, anyway, but you only use him in a couple missions. One of them is a boring stealth mission, however most of the time you just press a button and he attacks enemies. Okay, cool, I guess? It’s not bad, but it’s not good.
                Fair enough though, Ghosts, I know that multi-player is where you excel. Some people don’t even play the Call of Duty campaigns. So does the multi-player hold up? I would say yes, again, if you like what the series has always done, there’s a lot to like here.
                I give the series props for being like Halo and offering a bunch of interesting game types. As much as I love Killzone and their warzones, I’ve always hoped that Killzone would do a little more like Call of Duty in that regard (but only that regard), and offer more choices of games to play… even if I mostly play deathmatch, having the variety is nice. There is variety here. They’ve added some new games, and kept the classics. I can’t criticize them at all for this. There is still a lot of excitement to be had here.
                They also shifted the levelling system around a little bit, and this too is a positive, because using their new point system, there’s less of a gap between level 50s and level 1s, outside of skill. Never found Call of Duty to be as much of a skill-based shooter as some others, and this does a decent job of rectifying that a little bit. Good job on that too, but I still get murdered by everyone because I suck!
                They’ve also made environments a little more destructible. I’ve always said that making things more destructible is a next-gen idea that I can get behind, because it vastly improves the gameplay. Ghosts is no Battlefield, and even the combustible environments are a bit scripted and unimpressive. But they aren’t bad… they are an improvement, ultimately. Shooting a pipe and having smoke fill the area is a welcome inclusion, so I won’t hate on it or make fun of it.
                They also have online split-screen, which I loved about MW3 (and was the main reason I played it as much as I did), and since it returns, I have to say, thank you.
                If you are into the multi-player in the other games, you will like this. I enjoy it, but like my 6 indicates, I don’t love it. I probably never will again. I wasn’t even going to play Ghosts but life took me down this road anyway.
                The most interesting feature to appear in Ghosts is Extinction Mode. Instead of zombies, like in Black Ops, you have to drill hives and kill aliens. Even though it’s played mostly straight (god forbid they be funny), it’s nice to see Infinity Ward include a left-field choice like aliens in their military game.
                The best aspect is that it’s not just a copy of zombies, but it is similar. The aliens are more interesting rivals than zombies here because zombies are usually predictable and aliens jump up on things and attack in different ways. You can scavenge for things to help you out, and use the environment to aid you in your fight against them, and all-in-all, I’d say Extinction is better than Spec Ops in every way.
                Just as a final remark before my closing statement, Ghosts doesn’t push the system graphically, but I’ve never felt that CoD really wanted to anyway. It’s a good looking game, but it’s not awe-inspiring. I often forget to even talk about graphics because graphics matter so little to me in relation to everything else, but I know some people do so there you go.
                Call of Duty: Ghosts is a good game. Hell, it’s probably a great game, just not to me. At this point, Call of Duty can go fuck itself. Until it offers something new, or at the very least stops getting released every year, it will probably continue to get scores like this from me. But to the fans, I’m happy that you get another game.
               
               
               

Monday, 25 November 2013

PS4 Launch Party - Oh Man This Is A Long Killzone: Shadow Fall Review



Written By: Tyler Selig

               

Rating: 9.5
Verdict: Killzone: Shadow Fall will not do anything to encourage non-Killzone fans to sign up, but there are certain aspects of it that are refreshing in a crowded genre.


            You’re going to look at this review and think, “Wow, a 9.5? Seriously?” It probably won’t help that I’m really considering giving it a 10 because while I know it has its flaws, I’m so willing to overlook them because they aren’t huge and I have such a good time playing. While I won’t apologize for that, I will explain a few things that will hopefully clarify how I approached this game.
                Firstly, I am a Killzone guy. If anybody actually watches On The Gamely, I think I’ve mentioned it in every video so far. I believe that a lot of gamers have a shooter or two that they gravitate towards, and Killzone is mine. There’s where my bias is. Some will close this review right now because of that, but games in a series are made for fans of the series, with hopes that they’ll bring in new fans. It’s why I can’t criticize an open Call of Duty fanboy for thinking a Call of Duty is a 10. They like the mechanics of the series just like I like the mechanics of Killzone. I believe reviewers should be honest about their biases but with that said I will try to do a good job in making this review appeal to both Killzone fans and people who aren’t familiar with it.
                I also put more emphasis on the multiplayer aspect of Shadow Fall than the campaign. Some people would give equal weight to both, while some would give campaign more. To me, Killzone is my multiplayer shooter so while this review does take the campaign into consideration, the final score is more dependent on the multiplayer. I would do the same thing for Battlefield 4 if I were reviewing it because to me, that’s a series that focuses more on multiplayer. I would say even Call of Duty should be approached like that. But I know other people have different opinions on what I’ve said in this paragraph. A solid single player experience can only help, but a solid multiplayer experience matters more to me.
                So let’s move on now. I’m breaking the review up into a few different sections, which is something I rarely do but it makes it easier for me to gather my thoughts this time around.


Single Player
                Killzone: Shadow Fall puts you in events that are largely influenced by the Cold War. You have your two rival groups, like always, but there is a wall separating them. I’m a huge fan of this kind of thing, so right from the get-go, I was intrigued by what they’d do with this. How would they handle potential social commentary? Would they nail a dystopian-type vibe? Would it be fun to shoot the Helghast once again?
                Killzone has never had real interesting characters that you could truly feel for. But a lot of shooters don’t. This game isn’t like The Darkness, where I was so invested in the characters that I actually felt sad. Killzone has always offered a more general look at things – less about the individuals (though certainly there are individuals), and more about the war between two sides. That doesn’t forgive not having characters you can cheer for, but it does put it in context. I will say that Shadow Fall is the closest I’ve gotten to really caring about the individuals. So that’s a plus.
                The series has also always had an extremely interesting story but wasn’t told well in the game. Seriously, if you read about the story, it’s got depth and intrigue, but the games don’t go into a lot of detail. It’s not as simple as “Good vs Evil,” but the games haven’t really done a great job showing that. Shadow Fall also did a better job of immersing me in the world, offering some really great audio logs, comic book pages and just better story telling in general. It’s a step up from the other games in the series in this regard as well.
                There are a couple major changes to the campaign this time around. It’s less of a corridor shooter (which really isn’t a bad thing… not all games have to be open) this time around, as Guerrilla Games went a more Crysis route. Now you can approach a lot of the situations more freely, whether that be stealth or guns blazing. I think the game tries to get you to focus on only taking on a few enemies at a time, because things get hectic when they know you’re there. Offering more choice to the player is a welcome change for the series, and makes the campaign better. It also gives us a few different things to do besides shoot, like free fall which gets intense or float around in areas with zero gravity.
                The other major change is the OWL. It’s a little drone that changes up the strategy in the game. You can drop a shield in front of you, use it to stun enemies, order it to attack enemies or use it to zip line to areas. You use it by selecting what option you want with the touchpad and then press L2 to deploy it. I’m not really convinced on the touchpad in general, but they didn’t complicate the matter which is nice.
                The AI is a bit of a problem. Sometimes the Helghast do stupid things like duck into cover right in front of me, or just run around like idiots. It’s not terrible, as most of the time they are smart enough to flank me, drop a turret, teleport or get into proper cover, but I can get behind people saying the AI is an issue. Small, because consistent AI in games seems to be a problem in the industry overall, but it’s there.
                The campaign has a good length, being over 10 hours. Some people complain about this, but this is where we are for the genre. Unless you’re playing an open-world game or an RPG, these are the type of lengths you get. So you get no complaint from me there, especially since there is a robust multiplayer mode packed in.


Multiplayer
                Here we are, the multiplayer – the thing I mainly come to Killzone for. Even in the first one me and a friend played that first and spent hours playing it that day. So does it live up to the standards set in the previous games? For the most part, yeah.
                I want to get the negatives out of the way so I can gush. I don’t know why Guerrilla Games made such a crappy post-match UI. It boggles my mind why they wouldn’t include your deaths. It has your kills and assists, but no deaths? Kill/death ratio has always matter more than how many kills you get, at least to me. They had a good UI for Killzone 3, and they over-complicated it for this sequel.
                This may only bother me, but I like it showed you where your party members were in Killzone 3. It allowed me and my older brother to find each other more easily.
                I also don’t understand why there is no chat in-game. It doesn’t matter to me because I have no desire to talk to most people and a lot of people just act like knobs, but at this point, how can you make an online game that doesn’t include this feature?
                Am I the only one who hates the base camp suicides? I know, only an idiot would run into their base, but I’m an idiot. I just wish they would have done it differently, like put up a wall that you can’t go through instead of giving you insta-death. Sometimes you just run up by mistake. If you’re going to have this kind of system and not one that changes the spawn points, just do it differently.
                I am hoping that Guerrilla Games hears the complaints regarding some of these and release a patch that changes this. These three things add up and dampen my experience a bit.
                Killzone: Shadow Fall offsets these issues by doing things a little bit differently than most shooters that it’s competing against. I have this issue where I don’t know if I like the multiplayer in Killzone 2/3 better than this, and it’s because of these changes. I appreciate them, I just am not sure which I would prefer. With that said, I like both and I respect what was done here immensely.
                Instead of a typical experience system where you level up after matches, this operates on a challenge system, meaning you do certain things like kill 25 people with a certain grenade or gun, or stun so many enemies, etc, in order to advance, unlock things or improve your abilities. I wasn’t sure how I would feel about this before the game came out because I felt like it could make me do stuff I didn’t want to do just so I could “level up.” Luckily, they handled this really well. The challenges make logical sense and it hasn’t really affected me that much. It does make me think a little bit more about how I want to approach my loadouts, and that’s a nice change. I can now say that my fears about that are cooled down, and like I said, I respect Guerrilla Games for driving down a different road for this one.
                They also overhauled the classes. From Killzone 2 and 3, they changed them up, but Killzone: Shadow Fall is a lot different. Sure, you still have abilities that you know and love/hate from previous games like Snipers going invisible, or air-support drones, but they give you three classes that are really customizable this time around. The classes are Support, Assault and Scout. This was another aspect I was unsure of. I don’t like every change they made, but there are some that I do.
                I enjoy the shield, for example. A lot. It changes up the gameplay severely, and I don’t think I have really mastered it by any means. It’s a blast seeing two opposing sides in a small room with shields all over the place. It just adds to everything. I don’t know if I’d say it makes it more “tactical” but it offers you something different to worry about.
                I was unsure of abilities like the Scout being able to teleport to a random spot, especially since the Scout is basically the sniper class and those bastards can already go invisible. But I feel like they handled it well by giving each class an ability they have to use and then a second one that they can choose.
                I miss certain abilities like being able to camouflage yourself as an enemy, and I don’t know why they took that out, but they did a good job of balancing the classes. All three are viable options, and all three have certain advantages and disadvantages. There are nit-picky issues for each like why certain guns don’t have a silencer, but maybe that’s only my problem and nobody else cares. I still think I’d prefer the class system that they gave in 2 and 3 more, but I do really enjoy this too. Like I’ve said before… Shadow Fall is a lot different. I respect both ways, and I’m unsure most of the time of which I’d prefer.
                The maps may be the best of the series. Only Killzone 2 can rival them. I’ve enjoyed pretty much every map to some extent, with some I love. They even sort-of brought back my favourite from Killzone 3 (the Boulevard), but changed things and named it The Remains. Levels like The Park, The Slums, The Remains and The Forest rival the best maps in the series, and even the weaker ones are good. There is variety in all of the maps, and there are a good amount of them (10 total, but not everyone is available in Deathmatch, which is a choice I’ve never understood).
                If I were a different type of player, I would lament the fact that Killzone games have never offered much in the way of multiplayer game types. I’m generally only a guy who plays one or two game types anyway so it doesn’t really bother me, though I wish they had “Capture The Flag.”
                With Shadow Fall, they changed it up though and this is a vast improvement. The classic Warzone mode shows up again, only this time you can customize the experience. So maybe you only want to play one of the different types that the Warzone offers… well now you can. Not only that but you can change what abilities are allowed, guns, etc. Whatever you want, it’s there. Warzone is still fun and chaotic, but now it’s nice to have those choices.
                So as you can see, multiplayer wasn’t just a fine-tuning this time around: it was an attempt to rearrange Killzone and give us a different experience while maintaining just enough elements to keep the franchise familiar.    
           
                               
General Things
                To end the review I’m just going to touch on a few things that are more general in nature.
                The game is beautiful. Obviously it’s a launch title so games will come out with better graphics, but damn it’s impressive. There was a moment late in the campaign that I just looked on in awe. Everything is fluid, the animation is solid, and it’s just a brilliant piece of technical wizardry. Some have said that this is all the game offers, but I obviously disagree. The game is a wonder to look at.
                The game still feels like Killzone. I can’t quite remember just how heavy Killzone 1 and 2 felt, but I think that those may have been a little heavier. The feel of real weight is what appeals to me, and it’s nice that they didn’t entirely get rid of that.
                The last thing I’m going to touch on is the music. They do a great job of making everything atmospheric, or foreboding. When the action kicks it up a notch, the music does it accordingly. It’s a pleasure to listen to the sounds during the campaign. I think this will go on to be an underrated soundtrack.
                In closing, Killzone: Shadow Fall is a shooter that tries to do things a little bit differently than most games in the genre and especially other games in the series. It has flaws, and maybe I just respect when people try to do something different more than others, but I don’t find any of the flaws to be that glaring. Or maybe I’m just a fanboy.
               So let me know what you think about this review or the game. I really feel like I could have said more to justify my stance, but I always look forward to the views of other people.