Showing posts with label rpg review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rpg review. Show all posts

Monday, 11 August 2014

Is Sacred 3 Even A Sacred Game? Peep The Review Here And Ignore That I Said "Peep"

Written By: Tyler
Platform Played On: PC


Despite never playing the first Sacred, I have a love for Sacred 2. It wasn't an easy love and it was one that we both had to work at, but it exists now and it's very strong. The first time I played Fallen Angel I hated it, but this was partially because I had yet to buy a TV that was capable of handling high-def graphics... so reading text on a screen was extremely difficult. In a game like Sacred 2 this was a huge problem. The second time I tried playing I didn't find the game that exciting, but I enjoyed it more. The third time is when I fell in love. I became head over heels in love with its particular brand of open-world RPG, the complex leveling system, the endless loot and even the humour. Some people felt it was flawed but fun, whereas I think it's one of the best games the genre has seen.

Because of this, I was ridiculously hyped for the next entry in this series. I played Sacred: Citadel to help ease the wait, but it didn't click with me. I didn't know then -- and I wish I did because I would have saved $50 -- that Citadel was a good indication of where Sacred 3 was going. It's not that the game was the same because Citadel is a side-scrolling beat 'em up and Sacred 3 is still a hack n' slash, but one could say the simplicity of Citadel has drifted its way over to Sacred 3.

There's this constant debate within the realm of criticism and people can't agree on whether a franchise should be allowed to change. Wars have been waged (I'm purposely being overdramatic) over whether we should evaluate games based solely on what they are and not on the brand, or if we should take the name into consideration when critiquing it. In layman's terms: should I take into consideration what Sacred 2 brought to the table when reviewing Sacred 3, or should I just write about what Sacred 3 offers?

The answer, in this case, is that I have to take into consideration what Sacred 2 gave me. I can't avoid it. I'm all for series changing and evolving, but do gamers not go to their franchises of choice to have that similar gameplay experience? Unless you're a franchise that is known to constantly reinvent yourself, there are always going to be fundamentals in the games we like that make us go back. I don't want to play a core Metal Gear if there isn't stealth. I don't want to play a core Killzone if it doesn't have that heavy feel that the series is known for. Spin-offs are fine, and the concept of Citadel was okay by me because it was cheap and it wasn't a core Sacred.

That Deep Silver completely shit the bed with Sacred 3 is grounds enough for a mid-year leader for my "Disappointment of the Year" award. It went from what should have been one of my favourite games of the year to what will surely be one of the worst.

I want to get the good out of the way, because even though it's hard to find, it is there. I think that the game is reasonably pretty, with a very colourful aesthetic. We often get dark and gloomy environments in games like this, which is great, so it is nice to see an ARPG that embraces lighter colours and a more "pleasant" atmosphere. The fauna is detailed and the world is lively. Blues, greens, yellows all blend together well to create levels that are, at the very least, nice to look at. It's not that the game redefines graphics, but it is solidly put together and I did notice, and appreciate, the care that they put into creating a world that, like Sacred 2, was a little bit different and more cheerful looking than other games within the genre.


The music is also not bad. It's not great, and it's a bit by the books, but it's serviceable and does what it can to give the game a more epic feel when it needs it. It's orchestrated, and relies pretty heavily on quick chants to get its message across. Think Skyrim but not as good. Hell, it lacks the ability to pull you into its world musically like even a game like Divinity: Original Sin does.

The story follows the same path as the soundtrack, giving us a plot that works fine in moving everything along but I can't see anybody being entranced by what they're giving us. Lord Zane has gotten in bed with demons and is trying to open the gates to the underworld, so the heroes have to band together to put an end to that. It's pretty generic Fantasy storytelling, but if I'm being honest I don't go to action-RPGs for their plot anyway. It'd be nice if something could come along and give us a truly worthwhile plot in the genre, but I have yet to really find anything beyond simply "good."

Like in Sacred 2, the story isn't entirely serious. It's about as lighthearted as a game about opening up the gates of Hell can be without flopping around in parody. There's a lot of humour in here, though I'd argue that it's more of an attempt than anything. There are a couple lines worthy of a chuckle here and there but I'm so sick of hearing my brother's character yell "Sexy!" Hearing the same lines over and over is very grating, and a lot of the lines are cheesy and don't work.

Those are the aspects of the game that I'd deem good, or at least decent, and when that's all the praise I can give something we're in trouble.

I've seen it said a few times that this game should be approached like Gauntlet, but Gauntlet is still fun today due to clever level design and intense action. Despite Gauntlet being better, I do see the comparison. Deep Silver has chosen to strip the game of its open-world elements and give us a streamlined, stage-based game. Instead of traversing the world, finding side-quests and picking up copious amounts of loot, you are simply placed in a stage and are expected to make your way to the end while battling hordes of enemies. It is Gauntlet in that regard.

There are some different types of stages but they all amount to the same thing: you kill lots. There are the story stages, and there are stages where you simply just have to kill all the enemies, and there are wave-based stages where you defeat, you got it, waves of enemies. Even the portals that give longer side-quests still amount to the same thing.



The only thing that could save this set-up would be to have stages with dynamic action set pieces or something. Have a lot of exciting, stressful things happen in a stage to keep you on your toes. Instead, it's mostly just floor traps, which are more of an annoyance than anything, or having to turn a wheel six times while groups of enemies attack you.

This is where it's difficult to separate it from its brand, and the game suffers immensely because of it. Did anybody who anticipated this release want a Gauntlet clone? No, we wanted a huge world to explore, we wanted loot and we wanted a complex leveling system because this is what the previous Sacred gave us.

The sad thing is, I could actually have done without the open-world aspects if they had to strip it away. I wouldn't have preferred it because it was one of the selling points of Sacred 2, but had it gone a more Diablo 3 route where it's always very clear where you have to go, with very minimal exploration... I would have been fine with it. I really just enjoy the genre when done right. We are at a point in gaming where people seem to rage if a game is linear, but I don't mind linear. I've always found these types of games to have tremendous replay value, so I'm okay with only having one direction to go in.

What bothers me is that they've made the game boring and pointless. Hack n' slash is repetitive by nature, yet games like Dynasty Warriors remain fun. However, in the action-RPG I find it difficult to muster up the energy to continue laying waste to entire armies if there isn't something connected to the action. That is always the loot and the leveling.



There isn't any loot in this game. You pick up money, health and energy orbs, and that's it. Laughably, sometimes at the end of the level the treasure chests or enemies will drop health orbs. These don't matter because you're at the end and you gain all your HP back anyway. Without sufficient amount of loot, it's very hard to even care about killing the enemies.

The same can be said with the lack of real level progression. Sure, you level up, but it's in a very hollow way. You don't have stats to manage and there's very little customization in anything. You can choose between leveling up your combat arts, your skills or your equipment, but it's so straight-forward that it seems more like a chore than anything. You only have a couple ways to go, and there's no experimentation to see what is best. You'll very quickly find what works and stick with it because there's only a few different combat arts per character. In terms of skills, you are able to level up things like blocking, dodging or reviving. The choice there is whether you want to be able to block or dodge, because you can only have one at a time. This applies to your combat arts as well, though you can actually have two of those equipped at a time. This is a significant departure from the system in Sacred 2, which is almost godly. It's one of my favourite in the genre.

Everything is basically just handed to you. Sure you can level up the amount of potions you can carry, but you are given two at the beginning of every stage so there's no continuity and excitement in managing your resources. 

The combat leaves a little to be desired as well. At first I thought it was interesting for the genre, with something as silly as being able to roll being a plus because there aren't a lot of ARPGs that actually allow you to roll or block. It seems like a novelty at this point, but it's welcome. Unfortunately that wore off really quickly when I realized that it's still the same ol', same ol'. You have a special attack meant to break shields, but that overstays its welcome and just ends up seeming like a way to lazily add difficulty (another sore sport because the difficulty spikes are so uneven and annoying). A long with that you have two combat arts equipped on you, and of course the left mouse button is your basic attack.

Striking your foes is satisfying but it lacks the oomph of a game like Diablo 3. Regardless, it is reasonably fulfilling to lay siege to enemies. 

My biggest problem with the combat is one that I imagine would be fixed by using a controller, but I don't currently have a PC controller (just ordered one last night actually... yes I know you care about that): the controls. You move with WASD, but you attack in the direction that your mouse cursor is pointing. I hate this choice in pretty much any game because it makes it frustrating to attack where you want, or more specifically, dodging is a pain in the ass because logic tells you that you'll roll left when you're facing right, but the game tells you you'll roll right when you're facing left because you were pointing that way. This may seem like a silly criticism to some, but it heavily impacted the game for me.

It doesn't help that sometimes the game just ignores what you want entirely. I was playing as the Seraphim -- because it's Sacred and someone has to -- and she has a move where she jumps in the air and lands where you've pointed and does damage to any enemy close to where she landed. Only sometime she jumps in the opposite direction from where I'm pointing. The first few times this happened I thought I was just terrible but while that is true, it isn't why. It seems that the game incorrectly registers it sometimes. I also found that it didn't really send her exactly where I wanted it to.

Which brings me to the final part of my review, where I nitpick some smaller problems that just made me hate the game more. I had a lot of problem playing online. For one, my brother couldn't seem to join my game when I invited him so I'd have to just join him.

From my experience, and I'm well aware that this could differ for people, the person who was hosting the game seemed to run into issues where if you tried using your mouse to click options it wouldn't click the right one so you'd have to use the arrow keys and enter to be affective. The person joining the game ran into lag and constant yoyoing -- I don't know if this is an actual term but I heard my brother say it and I like it -- and it got frustrating. You'd fly back and forth constantly if you were not the host.


Even quitting out of the game is stupid. When you finally click the option to quit your game on the main menu, you actually have to hit the ESC key again. Why? Why would you do this? Normally in a review I'd ignore this or give it a quick mention in the middle of another paragraph but no, not only does this game not want me to have fun... it doesn't want me to quit either. It's like an abusive husband. Or wife, because we here at On The Gamely believe in gender equality.


It's not that these problems are huge. The yoyoing online was a problem, but these minor problems add up and when they're coupled with how terrible the game in other ways, it just amplifies them.

I hate Sacred 3, and from the looks of things, most people do too. The best that I've seen is that it's okay and when you don't look at it as a Sacred game, it's not too bad. When I first started the game I could have gotten behind that, but after spending some time with it, all I see is a lackluster new entry in a series I love, infested with poor game design.




Rating: 3/10
Verdict: Sacred 3 will crap on fans of the series, but even if one can separate themselves from the brand and look at the game as it is, it's still a very shallow experience. 

This is me right now, in case you didn't guess that.

Thursday, 10 July 2014

All Arguments Should Be Solved With Rock-Paper-Scissors -- A Divinity: Original Sin Review

Written By: Tyler
Platform Played On: PC



Rating: 9/10
Verdict: Divinity: Original Sin could use a little bit of polish here and there, and there are some minor design choices that I don't agree with... but despite all that this is a fantastic RPG in the vein of the classic computer RPGs.


Are you tired of games that hold your hand and tell you exactly where to go, who to see, and even help you wipe your own ass? Enter Divinity: Original Sin, the latest installment in the Divinity series.

In Divinity: Original Sin, you play as Sourcehunters and you're doing what that name implies. trying to rid the world of that pesky Source (not the game engine, though that would be neat considering I got the game on the platform that Valve owns). You begin your tale as two characters that you get to create, and the first main quest you end up doing is investigating a murder. From there, things get deeper and more complex.


Character creation seems like a good place to start. When you start a new game, you have the opportunity to create two characters who will end up interacting with one another throughout the game. There is a good variety of classes to choose from, abilities and traits to choose and statistics to level up. Leveling up ends up being in-depth but not overly so. It never reaches the point where you're confused but some levels allow you to level up three different things, but most levels allow two: abilities and stats. The only problem, at first, with this is that the game doesn't really explain much about things like skills so there's a little bit of trial-and-error involved. Of course, it all becomes clear but that initial creation screen is a little daunting because of it.

There's a reason that you create two characters as opposed to one. You can actually play this game co-op because of this, though that's not something I have done because it seems more like a single-player experience for me. However, I can see how co-op would be fun because the other reason you create two characters is because they end up having conversations with each other and you can choose whether they agree or disagree. Maybe your one character is more violent and goes one way, only to have the other be a voice of reason. Or perhaps they just agree with each other. The joy of Divinity: Original Sin is that not only can you make these choices, but they actually impact the game and your own statistics.

For example, my male first character agreed with the female second character, and "Romantic +1" flashed on the screen. You will see things like this continuously throughout the game, and if you press I, which is your inventory/character screen, you can keep track of what their relationship is. This will provide bonuses or debuffs.

It's important to note that you can develop your character however you see fit, basically. You can put points into anything, but obviously you'll want to specialize in some things to get the maximum effect. You don't put points into learning spells and techniques, but rather you acquire skill books. How many spells you can have of each type is dependent on how much you've leveled up each particular skill. Divinity: Original Sin has a system where you can choose to forget spells in order to replace them with another. But be careful, because these aren't like your first heartbreak -- once they're gone, they're gone, and the remains of that broken alliance will not stay with you. The spells will leave too.

Choice reigns supreme in this game on pretty much all fronts. If there's something you want to do in the game and it makes logical sense in context of the world, then you very well might be able to do it. I'll just give a few examples of some of the things you can do.

  • You can't unlock a door because you don't have the key. No problem! Just break it down using your weapon (but be careful because they have levels of durability). Better yet, just use magic to do it.
  • You are a kleptomaniac and you're standing in a shop, but there are people all over the place and you're trying to keep a good reputation among the townspeople. Just use your party members to distract the people by getting them involved in conversations and use one character to walk around and loot the place senseless. This is incredibly satisfying.
  • There's a troll guarding a bridge, and he wants toll money. You don't have any, so you could intimidate him, reason with him or charm him. This will bring up the funny yet alluring rock-paper-scissors argument system where you have to win a few games of it, unless your charm is infinitely higher than the other person. It sounds silly, but I like it.
Those are just three examples, but it all adds up to a game where you feel like you can influence what goes on around you. Between how you interact with the world and how you level up your characters, it's very easy to feel like you're actually involved in this world.

This choice is a double-edged sword in ways too. There's a brief tutorial at the beginning if you want it, but it probably won't prepare you for what this game has to offer. It gives the basics, but it's all a little disorienting once you begin. The game harkens back to a time where there was very little hand-holding. There won't be waypoints telling you where to go all of the time, and the journal doesn't always tell you where to go so it's best to try to remember what people say to you because if you forget you may not be able to easily find out again.

Once a while something will flash on screen to give you directions, and the journal will on occasion be enough, but there's no denying that this game wants you to pay attention. You can look through previous dialogue but that's just a pain because there isn't an easy way to sort through it. In this day and age where games often lead you along, this could be seen as a refreshing game mechanic to some. I am torn on it, if I'm being honest, and I'm not afraid to lose my gamer-cred by saying this: I don't mind being able to click on a quest and get told where to go.

Luckily though, they've done a pretty good job of making being lost a viable action. It's a beautifully realized, colourful and vibrant world so exploring it is nice on the eyes. It's also not a cinematic RPG so it doesn't take you away from the game.





There are also a lot of quests in this game, and even if you don't know where to go, wander around and you will find a quest. They're scattered throughout the world, and the best part of them is that they're actually fun to do.


That's because they aren't just fetch-quests. Sure, in any game like this there's that element, and I'm okay with it, but there are a bunch of ways to do things a lot of the time, and because the game doesn't hold your hand, there's enjoyment in discovering it yourself. Even the beginning of the main quest, where you investigate a murder, ends up actually being a murder investigation where you walk around, talk to people and get involved. It's not L.A. Noire by any means in the way it handles a crime scene, but for an RPG of this type, it's pretty genius quest design. It doesn't stop there, but I don't like to give away much of games when I review them.

While I don't actually think that the plot is anything innovative or intriguing, it does handle it relatively gracefully with a lot of reading and a sense of humour. Some of the quests are a little silly, and the characters alternate between light-hearted and deadly serious, and this extends to the NPCs as well. There are also funny little touches thrown in here and there, such as your character disguising himself as a rock, or a bush, when he/she is sneaking around.


I have a few minor gripes that I should finally touch on because I've basically been gushing this entire time. The shop system is a lot different than most RPGs which makes an experience we've done a million times feel fresh, but I'm only half into it. You can walk around and barter with anybody in the game that isn't an enemy, and they may have money or they may not. They always have items to sell but it may not be much. It's an amusing take on the economical structure of the world because a lot of people appear to be poor, but sometimes it's annoying walking around town trying to find someone you can sell yourself to.  It'd be nice to just have a go-to hub where you can sell everything once in a while.

The game makes it a little annoying to do mundane tasks such as comparing your inventory when you're shopping. You can't just press the button to scroll to the next one, you have to actually click on the character portrait on the side in order to choose them. Otherwise you could be comparing a weapon that someone is selling with the weapon you're holding, only it's focused on the character you're currently controlling rather than the inventory screen that you have up. The lack of polish in some of the areas of the game add length to the game that shouldn't be there, and having to walk around town trying to find someone to sell things to is not what I call "real" gameplay. It's fluff, it's pretend, it doesn't make playing the game more positive and only extends it in the most superficial way.

Keep in mind that those criticisms are extremely light and do very little to detract from my own enjoyment. I just found that sometimes inventory management was more of a chore than it should have been.

I purposely left the combat until the end because it could be the best part of the game. It is turn-based, and not unlike what we've seen before in that regard, but the developers have put a lot of effort into making each battle its own entity, rather than just a series of "blah" encounters.

You have your bar at the bottom, and they all have cool-down periods. You have so many action points per turn, which can be preserved and added to the next turn, and everything takes up an amount of points. Obviously AP is key in combat, and as a side-note, you can equip weapons that are above your level but your AP usage will be higher because of it.

The game allows you to manipulate the elements in fascinating ways. Here's a very basic scenario to explain what I mean. I'm in combat, and it's an area that has a lot of fire on the ground. Not wanting to be inflicted with a burning status (which will take away my HP each turn, much like poison), I cast a rain spell that puts out the fire and allows me to walk on it freely. In the process I've just made myself, my team and the enemies "wet," which is also an ailment. The enemies were on fire before but now they are normal, and there was one particular enemy who would have exploded once hit but the rain put out his fuse, rendering him useless. Not only have I made the enemies less dangerous, but if I use a shock spell I will inflict more damage because, as you know, if you blend water and electricity together... unfortunate things happen.

Before I learned to settle all disputes with Smash Brothers, I used Rock-Paper-Scissors.

That's just one example of what can happen, but it's something that makes battles interesting. If you decide to play Divinity: Original Sin, be prepared for this kind of thing to happen. Also be prepared to be frozen, tripped, poisoned, lit on fire, and a host of other things in your playthrough, because the enemies are nasty. Be smart, and use the environment to your advantage, and you will survive.

As you can see, if you've put yourself through reading my crap, Divinity: Original Sin is one of the best RPGs of the year. So far it's probably the most complex. Though the story isn't outstanding, and there's a lack of polish in some miniscule ways, it's a compelling, addictive RPG that is easy to sink a lot of hours into. Just be prepared to work for everything you accomplish because while the game isn't crushingly difficult, it likes to slap you around a bit.